General Description of The Battle
The Battle of the Chinese Farm took place during
October 15 to October 17, 1973 between the Egyptian Army and the Israel Defense
Forces (IDF), as part of the Yom Kippur War. It was fought in the Sinai
Peninsula, north of the Great Bitter Lake (GBL) and just east of the Suez Canal,
near an Egyptian agricultural research station. The battle began when the IDF
launched Operation Abiray-Lev ("Stouthearted Men"), attempting
to establish a corridor to the canal and allow bridges to be laid for a
crossing. Accordingly, the Israelis attacked Egyptian forces in and around the
Chinese Farm.
Battle
As of the night of October 15/16, 16th
Infantry Brigade unit bore the main brunt of Israeli attacks throughout the
duration of the battle.
Matt had
been informed that the crossing area and its environs were clear of Egyptian
forces but, out of caution, ordered his tank company to deploy at the
Lexicon-Tirtur junction to confront any Egyptian movements towards the crossing
site, just 800 meters (2,600 feet) south of the crossroads. The entire
company was destroyed after it was ambushed by Egyptian infantry of the 16th
Brigade. The company commander was killed and most of his men were casualties,
unbeknown to Matt. Meanwhile, Israeli artillery batteries opened fire on the
landing site on the west bank, landing around 70 tons of shells and ordnance.
In fact, the opposite bank was completely clear of Egyptian troops. The
crossing finally got underway at 1:35 AM, over five hours behind schedule. By
9:00 AM there were 2,000 paratroopers across, along with a battalion of thirty
tanks. The Israelis sent raiding parties attacking Egyptian SAMs on the west
bank, while securing a 4-kilometer-deep bridgehead without facing resistance.
Tuvia
Raviv's armored brigade began its diversionary attack against the 16th
Division's bridgehead at 5:00 PM on October 15, striking at the bridgehead's
center from the east, after a fire preparation. It was repulsed by the Egyptians,
as had been expected, but succeeded in its purpose. When the 16th Division's
southern flank came under increasing Israeli attack it was assumed that the
Israeli objective was to roll up the Egyptian Second Army's right flank, not to
open a corridor to the west bank for Israeli forces to cross the canal. For the
next 24 hours this remained the general impression among Egyptian commanders,
actions henceforth were driven according to that impression. Had they
discovered Israeli intentions earlier the Egyptians would almost certainly have
been able to defeat the Israeli operation, in light of the greater strength of
their forces and reserves near the Deversoir area, on the east and west banks
of the Suez Canal.
Lexicon-Tirtur Junction
While the paratroopers prepared to
cross Reshef was informed that Akavish had been closed again by Egyptian
infantry units soon after his passing. He sent one armored battalion to clear
the road and committed his remaining three armored and three mechanized
battalions to push northwards and secure Tirtur and the Chinese Farm.
An infantry
battalion, forming the right flank of Abd el-Hamid's 16th Brigade, was in
position to defend the Lexicon-Tirtur crossroads. Initially Reshef sent two
armored battalions northward on Lexicon. As the Israeli tanks neared the
infantry battalion they opened heavy fire with anti-tank weapons. They
destroyed 27 tanks during this engagement, although seven Israeli tanks managed
to break through the battalion's westernmost position on Lexicon and advance
northwards to al-Galaa'. Thereafter 'Abd el-Hamid ordered tank-hunting squads –
groups of ten equipped with RPG-7 rockets and RPG-43 grenades – to deploy
around al-Galaa' and destroy those tanks that penetrated, he also sent a tank
company to reinforce the infantry battalion.
At night
Reshef moved with his remaining forces north along the canal bank. Bypassing
the 16th Brigade's positions, the Israelis soon found themselves in the center
of a huge administrative area and vehicle park. Reshef's brigade had stumbled
into the command and supply bases of the Egyptian 16th and 21st Divisions. The
base was located near the canal on the assumption that it was the safest
location from Israeli attacks, which was expected to come from the east where
the defenses were strongest, not from the south where defenses and security
measures were weakest. Both sides immediately opened fire on each other, inadvertently
leading to the destruction of supply trucks and SAM launchers. The Egyptians
managed to organize a counterattack by units of the 21st Division; a battalion
of the 14th Brigade and a battalion (less one company) of the 18th Brigade. The
tanks repelled the Israelis, who sustained significant losses from vastly
overwhelming opposing forces.
Brigadier General Hafez, commanding the
16th Infantry Division, planned to contain the Israeli attack from the south by
having the 18th Mechanized Brigade occupy defenses north of the Chinese Farm,
directly behind the 16th Infantry Brigade, but without its organic tank
battalion which was designated as part of the division's reserve. The 1st
Armored Brigade was moved from its positions southward to occupy positions
between Lateral Road and the canal, on the right flank of the 18th Brigade.
Upon the brigade's arrival it engaged Israeli armor from Reshef's brigade in
al-Galaa', Egyptian armor destroyed around 15 tanks and several half-tracks. At
around 1:00 PM sorties of Egyptian Su-7s destroyed many Israeli tanks in
ground-attack missions over al-Galaa' village. The 1st Brigade countered a
flanking attempt on its left at 2:00 PM by a tank battalion, thwarting the
attack and destroying ten tanks. During its engagements on October 16 the 21st
Division managed to destroy over 50 Israeli tanks and APCs, while subject to
frequent Israeli air strikes and artillery barrages. The 1st Brigade accounted
for most of the kills, while suffering fewer losses.
Meanwhile one of Reshef's mechanized
battalions, commanded by Major Nathan Shunari, was reinforced with
company-sized remnants of the 40th Tank Battalion now commanded by Captain
Gideon Giladi after the previous battalion commander had been wounded. Shunari
was ordered to seize the Lexicon-Tirtur junction. He sent the tank company
ahead first, which initially reported no Egyptian units, and Shunari dispatched
an infantry unit in six half-tracks to the junction. Upon reaching it they
discovered that the tank company had already been destroyed and Giladi killed.
Soon the vehicles began receiving heavy fire stopping their advance. The unit
commander reported casualties and Shunari ordered the remainder of his
battalion to aid the pinned-down Israelis. Attempts to rescue the infantry
failed and the Egyptian battalion, defending the junction, directed heavy
firepower against the area aided by the brigade's artillery. The Egyptian
defenders had managed to catch the Israelis in a prepared killing zone.
Shunari, whose troops lacked cover and were threatened with destruction,
regrouped some of his forces and managed to escape the area in vehicles but the
infantry-half-track unit, first sent to the crossroads, remained pinned down.
Reshef sent another tank company to
rescue the infantrymen. The tanks advanced towards the Chinese Farm from the
south. As they neared the farm, and the village, a downpour of anti-tank and
artillery fire forced the company to retreat. Nathan kept pleading with Rehsef
to send additional support, unaware he was facing superior Egyptian forces
after entering the administrative bases of the Egyptian 16th and 21st
Divisions. With no help coming the unit commander had his men carry the wounded
and attempted to leave the battlefield, tasking two sections of heavy machine
guns with providing cover to the force. As the Israelis slowly made their way
back to their lines a group of Egyptian tanks intercepted, wiping out the
Israeli force.
Despite the debacle Reshef remained
determined to seize the junction, giving the task to the division's
reconnaissance battalion attached to his brigade. To achieve surprise the
battalion maneuvered to attack at 3:00 AM from the west, as the Egyptians were
preparing for further attacks from the south and east. As the Israelis attacked
Lt. Col. Brom was killed, barely thirty meters from Egyptian positions,
disrupting his battalion's assault. The Israelis sustained losses but managed
to retreat. Soon after a tank company attacked the crossroads at 4:00 AM on
October 16 but also withdrew after losing three tanks.
By 4:00 AM on October 16 Reshef's
brigade, which began the operation with 97 tanks, had lost 56 tanks in just twelve
hours of fighting with only 41 tanks remaining. Although seizing the crossing
site had been accomplished easily stiff resistance had prevented Reshef from
completing his remaining objectives, namely opening the routes to the canal and
securing a corridor. Reshef's force would further drop to just 27 tanks by
noon. As a whole, Sharon's division had lost some 300 killed and 1,000 wounded
that night. To help Reshef secure the corridor Sharon supplied him with two
tank battalions by 6:00 PM, propping his numbers up to 81 tanks.
Hearing reports of the heavy fighting
taking place between the junction and the Chinese Farm, Dayan suggested
withdrawing Matt's brigade and canceling the operation. He voiced concerns that
the paratroopers were threatened with annihilation and noted that all attempts
to open a corridor for the bridges to be laid had failed. Gonen rejected the
suggestion stating that, "If we knew in advance this was going to happen
we would not have started the crossing operation, but now that we have crossed
then let us follow through to the bitter end." Bar-Lev concurred with
Gonen and Dayan decided not to press his suggestion. At around 6:00 AM Golda
Meir telephoned Dayan to inquire of the situation. Dayan informed her that the
bridges had not yet been laid and that the Egyptians had closed the routes leading
to Deveroir. He also stated there were high hopes that Egyptian resistance
would be overcome and that the bridges would be laid during the morning. Dayan
also told her that Matt's paratrooper brigade had crossed to the west bank
without encountering resistance and that Southern Command, as yet, had no
intentions of withdrawing the brigade even if the bridge-laying was delayed.
In the morning, shortly after dawn,
Reshef conducted a reconnaissance of the battlefield from a hilltop. He saw
that the Egyptians had set up a strong blocking position defending the
junction, composed of Egyptian tanks situated in hull-down positions and
infantrymen in foxholes and the now-dry irrigation ditches of the Chinese Farm.
The infantry were from the 16th Brigade's right-flank battalion and had the
support of recoilless rifles, RPG-7s and some manually guided AT-3 Sagger
missiles. Reshef discovered that the Egyptians had mined both sides of Lexicon
Road, to which he had lost several of his tanks.
Reshef decided to change fighting
tactics. He personally commanded the 40th Armored Battalions, after reinforcing
it with tanks salvaged and repaired from the previous night's fighting, and
maneuvered to attack from the west – i.e.: from the direction of the canal –
hitting Egyptian positions in the flank while a tank company and an infantry
company attacked from south to north. Reshef's forces engaged the Egyptians
from long range, picking off defensive positions from afar, while using
alternate fire and movement to advance to the crossroads. The infantry
battalion, exhausted by continuous fighting and suffering from a severe lack of
ammunition, soon withdrew allowing the Israelis to at last seize the junction.
In the meantime other difficulties were
surfacing. Sharon reported to Southern Command that the roller bridge, being
towed by Erez's brigade, had been damaged in one of its sections and that the
engineers needed a few hours to repair it. He also requested additional forces
to help secure the corridor, noting the stiff resistance facing Reshef's
brigade. Sharon's report prompted Bar-Lev to alert Adan to prepare to open the
corridor with his division. Sharon argued for Adan's division to cross the
canal on rafts and to proceed with Operation Abiray-Lev without waiting for the
bridges. Both Gonen and Bar-Lev rejected Sharon's suggestion since, without a
secure corridor to the canal, Israeli forces on the west bank would be
threatened with encirclement. Subsequently Bar-Lev ordered that no more Israeli
forces or equipment would cross to the west bank until the bridges had been
laid.
After receiving reinforcements Reshef
focused on clearing the Tirtur Road. He left a battalion of around thirty tanks
between the junction and the western part of the Chinese Farm, and prepared to
attack with two armored battalions provided by Sharon. He concentrated on the
section of the Tirtur Road defended by an Egyptian battalion forming the left
flank of the 16th Infantry Brigade. One of Reshef's battalions attacked from
the north-east, the other from the west. The Egyptian battalion managed to halt
the advance aided by fire from tanks and anti-tank weapons on the slopes of
Missouri, a hill north-west of the Chinese Farm, causing Reshef to break off
his attack.
This last attempt left Reshef's brigade
in a desperate situation. He had 27 tanks remaining and was running short on
ammunition and supplies. Reshef requested authorization from Sharon to withdraw
his brigade to Fort Lakekan, to regroup his forces and allow them to regain
combat effectiveness.
Israeli
Reinforcement
The unexpected Egyptian resistance forced Israeli Southern
Command to change its plans. Visiting Adan's advance command post Gonen noted
that "Sharon has disappointed us" and handed Adan the task of moving the
pontoon bridge to the canal. Adan was to prepare to clear the Akavish and
Tirtur Roads to deploy the bridges. Gonen informed Sharon of Adan's new orders
and tasked Sharon with capturing the Chinese Farm and Egyptian positions near
the farm and the canal. In need of regrouping his forces Sharon suggested that
he capture the farm, once Adan had cleared the routes to the canal, and Gonen
consented. In a later meeting with Dayan and Bar-Lev, Gonen reiterated the
latter's statement that no more forces would cross until the bridges were laid,
and added that should the situation worsen the paratroopers may be withdrawn.
The 162nd Division, concentrated south of
Tasa, had been standing-by to cross the canal since dawn on October 16. The
division advanced towards the canal but movement was hampered by the massive
traffic jams on the roads leading to the canal. When Adan realized that Akavish
was closed, he ordered a tank battalion to make a turning maneuver through the
desert to reach Deversoir. When it arrived Sharon contacted Adan, explaining
Reshef's difficult situation, and requested that the battalion be placed under
his command. Adan accepted and Sharon in turn authorized Reshef's request to
pull back and regroup, replacing his brigade with the tank battalion.
After receiving his new orders Adan moved
his division to occupy a series of positions opposite 'Abd el-Hamid's 16th
Brigade. One of Adan's armored brigades had been placed as a reserve force
under Southern Command. 'Abd el-Hamid's left-flank infantry battalion, blocking
Tirtur, repelled Israeli tanks attacking westwards and thwarted Adan's efforts
to clear the road. Adan realized that, without infantry support, breaking
through the Egyptian positions would prove costly. However at 2:00 PM Southern
Command notified Adan that he was soon to be supplied with the 35th Paratrooper
Brigade, which had been transported by helicopters from Ras Sudar on the Gulf
of Suez to Refidem 80 kilometers (50 mi) east of the canal. The brigade
made its way to the canal in buses and was greatly delayed by the traffic on
Akavish road. Adan had expected the unit to arrive well before dusk but the
brigade commander Colonel Uzi Ya'iri only arrived at 10:00 PM, closer to
midnight. The rest of his brigade soon arrived, transported by helicopters
after the buses had come to a complete standstill.
Paratrooper
Effort
Adan met Ya'iri at Adan's former command post. Adan briefly
explained the situation and, in a short discussion, Ya'iri laid out his plan.
He was tasked with clearing Akavish and Tirtur. At 11:30 the paratroopers began
moving, with a battalion under Lieutenant Colonel Yitzhak Mordechai
spearheading the advance. Ya'iri, acting with a sense of urgency, had decided
to go into action without awaiting sufficient intelligence, or performing
adequate reconnaissance on Egyptian defenses. His unit lacked artillery
observers and, rather than wait for one to arrive, it was agreed the
paratroopers would request fire support of the 162nd Division's command net.
The brigade was acting without armor support.
The Israeli "roller bridge",
designed to be swiftly deployed on the canal. The fighting at the Chinese Farm
meant the bridge had to be towed across the desert rather than on a
purpose-built military road, and it reached the canal only after the pontoon
bridge had already been deployed.
After some time Mordechai's battalion had
reached an area where Tirtur and Akavish were closest, the distance between
them no wider than 2 kilometers (1.2 mi). At around 2:45 AM, they came
into contact with Abd el-Hamid's left-flank battalion, positioned around
Tirtur. The battalion directed effective artillery fire against the
paratroopers, who were also receiving heavy machine gun and small arms fire
from entrenched Egyptian infantry. The paratroopers attempted to assault the
machine gun positions, in places advancing to within a few meters of Egyptian
lines. The paratrooper companies spread out, but repeatedly failed to reach the
defenses. Israeli artillery fire was ineffective. Egyptian infantry were able
to suppress the paratroopers' movement and thwart flanking attempts. Most
company and platoon commanders were killed or wounded. Adan ordered Ya'iri to
narrow his brigade's front and focus on clearing Akavish instead, but the lead
paratrooper battalion was under such heavy fire that it was impossible to
maneuver.
With dawn nearing Adan realized that if
the pontoon bridge could not be brought to the canal during the few remaining
hours of dark, an entire day would pass without a bridge being laid across the
canal and in daylight the paratroopers would sustain more casualties. He sent a
half-track company to reconnoiter Akavish at 3:00. Half an hour later the
company reported it had reached the crossing site without encountering any
resistance. The Egyptian battalion fighting the paratroopers had focused all
their attention on the Israelis at Tirtur, ignoring activity on Akavish. Adan
took a risky decision, sending the irreplaceable pontoons down Akavish to the canal.
IDF Bulldozers cleared the road of wreckage and debris and the Israelis reached
Fort Lakekan before turning northwards, finally reaching the crossing site.
Bridge construction was started immediately by military engineers of the 143rd
Division.
At dawn Ya'iri requested approval from
Adan to withdraw his brigade, the paratroopers having thus far been
unsuccessful in reaching Egyptian lines. Gonen denied the request, approving
only medical evacuation for the wounded. This was countermanded after Bar-Lev
visited Adan at his command post and realized the gravity of the paratroopers'
situation. An armored battalion was tasked with covering the paratroopers but
was unable to locate them. The paratroopers released red smoke to pinpoint
their position but this backfired as the Egyptians also spotted the smoke,
directing accurate artillery fire against them and inflicting further
paratrooper casualties. The tanks assaulted the defenses but suffered losses
and fell back. It became evident that withdrawal could not be accomplished in
the open, APCs and half-tracks were brought up to extract the paratroopers and
the wounded—all the while under fire. The Israelis finally withdrew under cover
of friendly tanks. In 14 hours of almost uninterrupted combat the paratroopers
suffered heavy casualties with some 40–70 killed and 100 wounded. Ya'iri would
state that "We had suffered seventy casualties because we went into action
too hastily, without proper intelligence on the enemy's defenses." Armored
losses sustained during the withdrawal were also heavy.
Egyptian
Withdrawal
The Israeli armored brigades, principally those of Nir, Amir
and Raviv, continued engaging and attacking the 16th Brigade after the
paratroopers were withdrawn. The Israelis concentrated air and artillery
attacks against 21st Division's units from 5:00 AM. The Egyptians estimated
there were upwards of 80 Israeli tanks attacking their positions. At around
7:00 AM on October 17 the 21st Division received orders to evict Israeli armor
from the vicinity of al-Galaa' village and capture Fort Matzmed, as part of a
larger Egyptian effort to seal the Israeli penetration and destroy the
bridgehead on the west bank. Since Oraby had the 18th Mechanized Brigade in
defensive positions and stripped of its tank battalion, and the 14th Brigade
defending other parts of the Egyptian bridgehead, he tasked the 1st Brigade to
execute the attack with its remaining 53 tanks. At 8:00 AM the Egyptians
conducted an air and artillery strike on the area for some fifteen minutes,
after which the attack commenced. Egyptian tanks managed to destroy Israeli armor
near the village and reached the northern strongpoint of Fort Matzmed just
after 9:00 AM, in the face of heavy resistance. However they were soon repelled
by Israeli ground fire supported by air strikes. Israeli tanks then
counterattacked and managed to advance significantly. The armored battle
continued in a see-saw fashion until 9:00 PM, by which time the 1st Brigade had
restored its original lines. Meanwhile an attack by one of the 18th Brigade's
mechanized infantry battalions on al-Galaa', at 5:00 PM, failed with heavy
losses and ten tanks were then allocated to the brigade. Israeli armor had
occupied irrigation ditches around the farm and were entrenched in them, which
significantly enhanced their defensive position against Egyptian counterattacks.
Egyptian attacks directed against the Israeli corridor, or the bridgehead,
failed with heavy losses.
The 1st Brigade had just 33 tanks
remaining in its inventory after losing 20 tanks. This prompted Second Army
command to transfer a battalion of 21 tanks on October 18 from the 2nd Infantry
Division to the north to reinforce the dwindling tank numbers in 16th
Division's bridgehead. As the battalion moved south a large number of Israeli
aircraft attacked the formation. The battalion undertook evasive maneuvers,
turning eastwards and fanning out in the desert terrain, thereby avoiding
losses. The battalion was then attached to the 21st Division.
Abd el-Hamid meanwhile reported the dire
situation of his forces at 5:30 PM on October 17. The 16th Brigade had been in
heavy combat for three consecutive days – ammunition was running scarce and the
brigade was heavily outnumbered and outgunned due to losses, including the destruction
of its artillery units. Abd el-Hamid received orders from 16th Division
Headquarters to retreat, his brigade abandoned its Chinese Farms positions and
reinforced the lines of the 18th Mechanized Brigade to the north during the
night of October 17/18. This finally opened the Tirtur and Akavish roads to
Israeli forces, ensuring Operation Abiray-Lev would proceed. Missouri remained
in Egyptian hands though, posing a threat to the Israeli corridor to the canal.
Aftermath
At around 4:00 PM on October 17 the pontoon bridge had been
fully assembled, opening the first Israeli bridge across the canal. The roller
bridge was laid soon after at dawn on October 18 and, by the afternoon, Adan's
division crossed to the west bank followed by Kalman Magen's division. Adan,
supported by Magen, would go on to reach Suez after the failure of a United
Nations ceasefire, thereby cutting off two infantry divisions of the Egyptian
Third Field Army. Sharon also crossed with part of his division, simultaneously
trying to defend and expand the Israeli corridor to the Suez Canal—as well
attacking northwards on the west bank to Ismailia, in an attempt to similarly
cut off Second Army. His efforts bogged down and he was unable to reach
Ismailia, while attempts to seize critical positions and expand the Israeli
corridor on the east bank saw little to no success.
While ultimately an Israeli victory, the
Battle of the Chinese Farm has an especially infamous legacy among Israeli
participants, and it is remembered as one of the most brutal battles of the
war—and for the heavy losses it incurred on both Egyptians and Israelis. After
the battle had ended, Dayan visited the area of the battlefield and Reshef, who
accompanied him, said "Look at this valley of death." The minister,
taken aback by the great destruction before him, muttered in an undertone
"What you people have done here!" Later Dayan would recount that:
"I am no novice at war or battle scenes, but I have never seen such a
sight, not in reality, or in paintings, or in the worst war movies. Here was a
vast field of slaughter stretching as far as the eye could see." Sharon
would also provide his own poignant account of the aftermath: "It was as
if a hand-to-hand battle of armor had taken place... Coming close you could see
the Egyptian and Jewish dead lying side-by-side, soldiers who had jumped from
their burning tanks and died together. No picture could capture the horror of
the scene, none could encompass what had happened there."
The losses suffered by both the Egyptians
and the Israelis in the battle were severe. Israeli units suffered heavy
casualties in men and equipment; Reshef's armored losses during the first night
of the battle alone were comparable to Egyptian armored losses on the
disastrous October 14 offensive. For their part, the numbers of Egyptian
armored forces within 16th Division's bridgehead severely dwindled. As of 18
October the 21st Armored Division had no more than 40 tanks remaining, of an
original 136 tanks available at the start of the battle (not counting 21 tanks
received as reinforcements), while the 16th Infantry Division had just 20 tanks
remaining in its organic tank battalion. This attrition served Egypt's war
strategy of inflicting maximum casualties on the Israelis even though, from
another perspective, the initiative had passed to the Israelis during the
battle.
